New York police launch 911 call that revealed Very long Island serial killer situation: ‘There’s somebody just after me’

NEWYou can now hear to Online News 72h articles or blog posts!

New York police unveiled new facts about Prolonged Island’s cold case Gilgo Beach front serial slayings Friday, heading community with three earlier withheld 911 phone calls. They incorporate a call from the girl whose disappearance led investigators to a grotesque trove of bodies scattered close to a scenic, oceanfront highway.

The murders continue to be unsolved far more than a ten years after the search for lacking escort Shannan Gilbert, 24, led police to the bodies of multiple intercourse workers and other victims alongside an oceanfront highway east of New York Metropolis.

“There’s someone immediately after me,” Gilbert frequently instructed dispatchers in a connect with put at 4:51 a.m. on May 1, 2010. But she did not present a area much more distinct than in a property on Prolonged Island, someplace in the vicinity of Jones Beach.

“Can you trace wherever I am?” she requested.

Shannan Gilbert’s disappearance prompted a research of the place that uncovered a string of victims.
(Courtesy of Shannan Gilbert’s family/Suffolk County Police Division)


“No, I cannot,” the dispatcher replied.

Gilbert was contacting from a house in Oak Beach front, a gated local community on the Atlantic Ocean.

In the background, a person determined as Joseph Brewer can be listened to telling her it’s “time to go.”

One more person, Michael Pak, was waiting outside the house. Police explained he was her driver. But she refused to go with him and ran down the highway, according to authorities, knocking on neighbors’ doorways and boasting a person was chasing her.

As the get in touch with goes on, she seems increasingly distressed.

“What’s the issue, are you Ok?” Pak is read asking after Brewer claims he’s going upstairs.


“What are you gonna do to me?” Gilbert replies. 

The recording is muffled, but it sounds like he presents to travel her residence. 

“Are you gonna destroy me?” she says times later.

Police found more than 10 bodies in the area after beginning their search for Shannan Gilbert in 2010.

Law enforcement observed extra than 10 bodies in the area following starting their research for Shannan Gilbert in 2010.
(Suffolk County Law enforcement Department)

“Are you nuts?” he replies.

At numerous details in the phone, she seems to ignore the dispatcher, seemingly distracted. She continuously tells Pak, “Mike, cease it,” prompting the dispatcher to check with for his very last identify. Gilbert does not offer it.

In yet another portion of the 23-minute recording, she identifies herself and tells the dispatcher, “These individuals are striving to get rid of me.”

Right after an unresponsive part of the connect with — around 17 minutes in — she starts screaming. She vanished that evening, and the ensuing lookup for her uncovered various other bodies in the place. But although some of them might be connected to a single or more killers, police reported her relation to the investigation may possibly end there.

“Releasing the Shannan Gilbert 911 calls will not hinder this investigation,” Suffolk County Law enforcement Commissioner Rodney K. Harrison informed reporters all through a news convention announcing the launch of the recordings. “I persuade the community to listen to the overall get in touch with.”

Two other calls, from neighbors Gus Coletti and Barbara Brennan, served police hone in on Gilbert’s locale, despite the fact that it would be months before they discovered her remains. 

For the duration of the briefing, police unveiled that they thought Gilbert’s loss of life was an accident. They reiterated previous stories that she endured from mental disease and was identified to use drugs and said the side effects occasionally left her disoriented and irrational.

Due to the fact Harrison took the commissioner’s task New Year’s Eve, he has refocused the cold circumstance investigation, forming a multi-agency endeavor pressure and vowing to launch additional details and dispel myths and rumors bordering the 12-calendar year-aged investigation.

Just past 7 days, he discovered further information about the “Gilgo 4,” the very first victims located after the lookup for Gilbert commenced.

Counter-clockwise from left: Amber Lynn Costello, 27, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, Megan Waterman, 22 and Melissa Barthelemy, 24, disappeared after meeting with a client on Craigslist. The remains of the women were found in December 2010 at Gilgo Beach on Long Island. 

Counter-clockwise from left: Amber Lynn Costello, 27, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, Megan Waterman, 22 and Melissa Barthelemy, 24, disappeared immediately after meeting with a customer on Craigslist. The remains of the gals were identified in December 2010 at Gilgo Seashore on Lengthy Island. 
(Suffolk County Police Department)

“I would have taken the same route. These had been the four latest homicides, primarily based on how they were remaining in close proximity and the reality that they were being wrapped in burlap,” Joseph Giacalone, an adjunct professor at New York City’s John Jay School of Felony Justice, instructed Online News 72h Digital Friday. “This is the scenario that [Harrison] is on the lookout at hard. This is the a person he desires to remedy initially, and then we’ll see in which the other types go.”

Those people four victims, like Gilbert, worked as Craigslist escorts.

“I think [Suffolk Police] produced the suitable action in that course in which they are striving to place certain speculation to bed,” Giacalone mentioned.

Harrison, a former NYPD chief, is the most up-to-date in a line of Suffolk law enforcement commissioners to deal with the circumstance about the years. He kicked off his tenure with a vow to carry a refreshing approach to the stalled investigation.

“I like what Harrison is accomplishing, and I consider he’s got a method to his insanity,” Giacalone claimed. “This dude is an experienced investigator.” 

However, Giacalone did question the department’s choice to acquire a stance on Gilbert’s lead to of loss of life when the county professional medical examiner’s official autopsy was found it to be “undetermined.”

“When you’re working with an undetermined death, it is not up to the police section to arrive up with an opinion on what they think,” he reported. “When the ME kicks it back to you, it’s up to the police office to either show or disprove regardless of what they believe.”

The department’s conclusion that Gilbert did not die by murder appears to contradict the conclusions of a 2016 private autopsy commissioned by Gilbert’s spouse and children. 

Shannan Gilbert's disappearance prompted a search of the area that uncovered a string of victims.

Shannan Gilbert’s disappearance prompted a research of the place that uncovered a string of victims.
(Courtesy of Shannan Gilbert’s loved ones/Suffolk County Police Department)

NEW YORK Police Release NEW Video clips IN Extended ISLAND SERIAL KILLINGS, Improve REWARD TO $50K

Dr. Michael Baden, the famed forensic pathologist and former main health care examiner of New York City, was hired by the family members. He located “insufficient info to identify a definite result in of loss of life, but the autopsy conclusions are regular with homicidal strangulation.”

Essential bones in her throat were lacking, but the adjacent types experienced “a roughness at the margins.” He also discovered no drugs in her technique.

“It is my impression, based mostly on the circumstances of Shannon’s death and on the elements that I have reviewed, that there is no evidence that she died of normal disorder, of a drug overdose or of drowning,” he concluded. “There is inadequate information and facts to identify a definite trigger of loss of life, but the autopsy conclusions are regular with homicidal strangulation.”

John Ray, the lawyer symbolizing Gilbert’s estate who has now experienced obtain to the recordings, did not quickly react to Online News 72h Digital’s requests for comment.

Shannan Gilbert's disappearance prompted a search of the area that uncovered a string of victims.

Shannan Gilbert’s disappearance prompted a lookup of the region that uncovered a string of victims.
(Courtesy of Shannan Gilbert’s spouse and children/Suffolk County Law enforcement Department)

In a early morning interview with Long Island News Radio, right before the calls were produced to the broader community, he disputed the notion that Gilbert’s dying was not the result of foul participate in.

“The law enforcement section put out a fake narrative, a extremely strongly fake narrative about what transpired that early early morning of Might 1, 2010, and they based it … upon the misrepresentation that very little really substantial transpired and that Shannan was genuinely kind of irrational,” Ray stated. “All those factors are decidedly not genuine. And the tape definitely will demonstrate you that.”

Investigators say this belt found at one of the crime scenes related to the Gilgo Beach murders likely belongs to a suspect.

Investigators say this belt uncovered at 1 of the criminal offense scenes linked to the Gilgo Beach front murders possible belongs to a suspect.
(Suffolk County Police Office)

Suffolk law enforcement said they based their conclusions on a evaluation from the FBI’s Behavioral Investigation Unit as well as other evidence.

Click on In this article TO GET THE Online News 72h Application

Law enforcement found Gilbert’s overall body south of the parkway. The other victims have been on the north side. She experienced her identification and was carrying revenue. And she had a historical past of psychological ailment and substance abuse that detectives explained could demonstrate her evident confusion and irrationality.

“The prevailing feeling is that Shannan’s death, even though tragic, is not a murder,” mentioned Suffolk County Law enforcement Lt. Kevin Beyrer.

Tragedy struck her family members all over again a couple of many years later, when her sister, Sarra Gilbert, was accused of killing her mother, Mari Gilbert.

Online News 72h’ Emmett Jones and Sarah Rumpf contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Related Articles

Back to top button